The Last Order
POLITICAL FICTION
The Last Order
The Fall of a Ruler, the Silence of His Court and the Long Shadow of Tyranny
A political short story inspired by history, Plato’s Republic and the tragic irony of authoritarian power. Nothing in it has happened.
By Mareshet Yimer Meshesha
Independent Analyst
Editor’s note: The following is a work of fiction. It imagines events that have not occurred and does not report, predict or assert the death of any person. The Ethiopian Tribune publishes it as political allegory in the tradition of the philosophical dialogue. The views expressed are the author’s own.
AUTHOR’S DISCLAIMER
This is a work of political fiction. The reported death of Abiy Ahmed, the circumstances surrounding it and all events involving his final hours are entirely fictional and do not constitute a factual report, prediction or assertion that he has died.
The story is an exercise in political imagination and historical reflection. Its purpose is to examine the consequences of authoritarian government, the personalisation of state power, political fear and the subjugation of institutions and citizens.
It is not an endorsement of violence or extrajudicial action. Its central argument is that no individual should be indispensable to a nation, no ruler should be above the law, and no society should have to await the death of a leader to recover its freedom.
Prologue: The Silence at the Palace
Addis Ababa. A fictional November evening.
The news travelled through the corridors of power before it reached the streets.
Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed had collapsed.
At first, nobody believed it. Or perhaps everybody believed it but nobody dared say so.
Abiy Ahmed, the man whose voice had dominated Ethiopia’s political landscape for eight years, had been found unconscious in his private residence. The circumstances were unclear. His security detail had secured the premises. Senior officials had been summoned. His closest advisers were gathering in adjoining rooms, speaking in whispers.
For a man who had demanded absolute loyalty, the silence was extraordinary.
A senior official asked whether a doctor had been called.
Nobody answered.
Another suggested that the Prime Minister should be taken to hospital immediately.
A third cautioned that no decision could be made without authorisation from the Prime Minister’s office.
The absurdity of the situation was almost unbearable. The person whose authorisation they required was the very person who could no longer give it.
The senior security official looked at the others.
“Who is prepared to take responsibility?”
Silence.
For years, they had learnt that independent initiative was dangerous. A wrong decision could end a career, destroy a family or result in imprisonment. The safest course had always been to wait for instructions.
But the instructions did not come.
The doctors eventually arrived. The medical team worked desperately. The emergency response continued, but the situation was critical.
Hours later, the official announcement was made.
The Prime Minister was dead.
Within minutes, Ethiopia entered an unfamiliar political silence.
The man who had filled every available political space had suddenly left an enormous vacuum.
And in that silence, the country began asking questions that it had been afraid to ask for years.
Chapter One: The Men Who Could Not Speak
The first people to understand the implications were not the ordinary citizens.
They were the men and women who had surrounded the Prime Minister.
The ministers, advisers, generals, party officials and security chiefs who had built their political fortunes around his authority suddenly found themselves without the one person whose approval had become the organising principle of their professional lives.
They looked at one another.
Who was in charge?
Who had the authority to convene the cabinet?
Who could issue instructions to the military?
Who could guarantee the security of the government?
Who would protect them from the consequences of decisions made in the Prime Minister’s name?
For years, they had defended his policies, repeated his speeches, celebrated his achievements and explained away his failures.
Some had genuinely believed in him.
Others had simply understood the economics of political survival.
But now they discovered that they had built a political system in which almost nobody had learnt how to exercise independent judgement.
The constitution still existed. Parliament still existed. The courts still existed. The military still existed.
Yet the political machinery appeared paralysed.
It was an extraordinary demonstration of the danger of personalising the state.
A nation of more than a hundred million people had been made to appear dependent on one man’s authority.
Chapter Two: The Ghosts of History
History has witnessed this tragedy repeatedly.
Joseph Stalin built a political empire in which fear penetrated every institution, from the Kremlin to the smallest administrative office. Millions suffered through purges, forced collectivisation, executions, imprisonment and the Gulag system.
In March 1953, Stalin himself suffered a fatal stroke. His final hours became a grim illustration of the fear surrounding his authority. The precise conduct and motives of those around him remain subjects of historical discussion, but the episode exposed the consequences of a political environment in which independent action had become dangerous.
Mao Zedong mobilised an entire nation around revolutionary ideology and personal authority. The Great Leap Forward contributed to a catastrophic famine, while the Cultural Revolution devastated educational institutions, families, intellectual life and the country’s cultural heritage.
Adolf Hitler took a sophisticated industrial society and mobilised it towards aggressive war, racial persecution and genocide. Six million Jews were murdered in the Holocaust, alongside millions of other victims of Nazi persecution and mass violence. Europe was left devastated.
Idi Amin’s Uganda became synonymous with arbitrary detention, political murder, disappearances and economic destruction. His rule demonstrated how quickly a state can become an instrument of personal terror.
Augusto Pinochet’s Chile experienced a brutal dictatorship marked by executions, torture, enforced disappearances and systematic political repression. His government left deep divisions that continued long after his departure.
Francisco Franco ruled Spain through repression, political imprisonment, censorship and the suppression of dissent following the Spanish Civil War. His authoritarian legacy shaped Spanish political life for decades.
The Marcos dictatorship in the Philippines accumulated extraordinary personal and family power. Martial law, corruption, human rights violations and the concentration of national wealth left lasting consequences for Philippine institutions.
The Kim dynasty in North Korea offers another disturbing example of personalised hereditary rule. Kim Il-sung established the system, Kim Jong-il consolidated it, and Kim Jong-un inherited it. Generations have lived under extensive political surveillance, restrictions on movement and expression, and a system that places the ruling family at the centre of national life.
Mengistu Haile Mariam’s Ethiopia experienced the Red Terror, widespread political executions, detention, displacement and devastating human suffering under the Derg.
These rulers differed in ideology, historical circumstances and methods. Their regimes should not be treated as identical. But their histories reveal a recurring danger: when the state becomes an instrument of personal or ideological domination, ordinary people bear the consequences.
The victims are not historical statistics.
They are mothers who never saw their children again, fathers who disappeared into prisons, students whose education was interrupted, intellectuals whose books were silenced, farmers who lost their land, families forced into exile and generations who inherited fear instead of opportunity.
The names of dictators occupy history books.
The names of their victims often disappear into unmarked graves.
“The names of dictators occupy history books. The names of their victims often disappear into unmarked graves.”
Chapter Three: The Ethiopian Question
Back in Addis Ababa, the fictional news of the Prime Minister’s death had produced an extraordinary mixture of grief, uncertainty, apprehension and relief.
There were citizens who mourned him. There were others who feared what might follow. Some simply wanted to know whether the fighting would stop.
For families in Amhara lands, the question was whether the guns would finally fall silent.
For communities in Oromia, the question was whether years of insecurity would give way to a genuine political settlement.
For families in Tigray, the question was whether the promises of peace, reconstruction and justice would finally be fulfilled.
For political prisoners, the question was whether the doors of the prisons would open.
For journalists and intellectuals, the question was whether they could finally write, speak and investigate without fear.
For the Ethiopian diaspora, the question was whether returning home might once again become a realistic possibility.
But another question emerged.
Would the system change, or would another individual simply inherit it?
The death of a ruler does not automatically produce freedom.
Stalin died, but the Soviet Union did not become a democracy overnight.
Mao died, but China had to confront the enormous consequences of his political legacy.
Franco died, but Spain required a carefully negotiated transition before establishing its modern democratic institutions.
Pinochet departed from the presidency, but Chile continued to grapple with the legacy of dictatorship.
The end of a ruler is not necessarily the end of the political system he created.
That is the lesson Ethiopia must understand.
Chapter Four: The Men Who Waited for Orders
In the Prime Minister’s former office, an adviser began collecting documents.
There were speeches, policy directives, security reports, photographs and records of cabinet decisions.
He found an old memorandum bearing the words:
The Prime Minister has directed…
Another stated:
In accordance with the Prime Minister’s vision…
A third read:
Following the Prime Minister’s personal instructions…
Page after page, the same pattern emerged.
Where were the independent decisions of ministers?
Where were the records of parliamentary scrutiny?
Where were the objections raised by professional advisers?
Where were the reports warning of impending humanitarian disasters?
Where were the assessments questioning the wisdom of military operations?
Had anybody spoken honestly when the truth was inconvenient?
Or had the machinery of government become an echo chamber?
The adviser stopped reading.
He understood something that had escaped him for years.
The problem was not simply that one man had accumulated too much authority.
The problem was that an entire political establishment had surrendered its responsibility to think independently.
They had become administrators of obedience.
And now, without the man who had commanded them, they did not know what to do.
Chapter Five: Socrates Enters the Courtroom
In a realm beyond the living, the fictional Prime Minister found himself standing before an unfamiliar assembly.
At its centre sat an elderly philosopher.
It was Socrates.
The philosopher looked at him without hostility.
“Tell me, Abiy,” he asked, “what is justice?”
The former Prime Minister began to speak, first in Amharic, then in Afaan Oromo, then in Tigrinya and finally in English, about national unity, sovereignty, development and the preservation of the Ethiopian state.
Socrates listened.
When Abiy finished, the philosopher asked another question.
“Is justice whatever the ruler declares to be necessary?”
“No,” came the answer.
“Then can a government be just if its citizens are afraid to question it?”
The former Prime Minister hesitated.
Socrates continued.
“Can a minister properly serve the people if he is afraid to tell the ruler the truth?”
No answer.
“Can a journalist be an enemy of the state simply because he investigates the conduct of government?”
Silence.
“Can a prisoner be considered guilty merely because he refuses to confess?”
The silence became unbearable.
Socrates stood.
“You have spoken of national unity. But did you understand that unity cannot be built upon fear? You have spoken of development. But did you understand that development cannot compensate for the destruction of human dignity? You built a great dam on the Abay. But did you not also raise walls between communities, until neighbours came to spill each other’s blood? You have spoken of sovereignty. But did you understand that the first responsibility of sovereignty is the protection of the people?”
He paused.
“Tell me, then, what was the purpose of all that power?”
“Tell me, then, what was the purpose of all that power?”
Abiy looked around the assembly.
For the first time, there was nobody to tell him what to say. No Deacon Daniel. No Abadula Gemeda, the old patron. No Getachew Reda. He was entirely alone.
Chapter Six: The Morning After
The fictional death announcement was followed by an extraordinary public gathering.
People assembled in Addis Ababa, Bahir Dar, Mekelle, Gondar, Hawassa, Dire Dawa, Jimma and countless smaller towns throughout the nation.
Some celebrated. Some mourned. Others simply watched.
There were no guarantees that violence would end.
There were no guarantees that the military would remain neutral.
There were no guarantees that the political establishment would permit a peaceful transition.
The country was at a crossroads.
The leaders of Cooperation for Existence, together with Ethiopian academics, lawyers, civic leaders and representatives of different communities, gathered to discuss a national transition.
Their first resolution was simple.
No individual should be permitted to inherit unlimited political authority.
Their second resolution was more difficult.
All political prisoners should have their cases independently reviewed, and anyone detained without lawful justification should be released.
Their third resolution concerned the armed forces.
The military must remain an institution of the Ethiopian state, subject to constitutional civilian oversight, rather than an instrument of any political party or individual.
Their fourth resolution addressed the victims.
There would be no national reconciliation without truth. There would be no lasting peace without accountability. There would be no constitutional settlement without the participation of the communities whose lives had been shaped by decades of political conflict.
The meeting ended without agreement on every issue.
But something had changed.
For the first time in a long time, disagreement was not treated as treason.
It was treated as the beginning of political life.
“For the first time in a long time, disagreement was not treated as treason. It was treated as the beginning of political life.”
Epilogue: A Nation Must Outlive Its Rulers
History has a peculiar way of remembering powerful men.
Stalin, Hitler, Mao, Idi Amin, Pinochet, Franco, Marcos, the Kim dynasty and Mengistu Haile Mariam once commanded armies, controlled governments, silenced critics and occupied the centre of their respective political universes. Some ruled through revolutionary ideology, others through nationalism, military power, racial supremacy or hereditary authority.
Their methods differed, but their victims shared a terrible experience: the loss of freedom, dignity, security and, for millions, life itself.
Their names remain in history. But so do the consequences of their rule.
Millions were murdered, imprisoned, displaced or driven into exile. Families were destroyed. Universities were silenced. Economies were distorted. Generations grew up learning that speaking the truth could be dangerous.
And yet, history teaches another lesson.
The departure of a dictator does not automatically liberate a nation.
The death of Stalin did not immediately dismantle the Soviet system. Mao’s death did not erase the consequences of the Cultural Revolution. Franco’s departure required a difficult political transition before Spain could establish a democratic constitutional order. The end of Pinochet’s rule did not instantly resolve Chile’s historical divisions.
The individual may disappear, but the political culture he created can survive him.
This is the real danger confronting Ethiopia.
In our fictional account, Abiy Ahmed’s death brought the machinery of government to a moment of paralysis. But the more important question was never whether he would be succeeded, mourned, condemned or forgotten.
It was whether Ethiopia would finally understand that no individual should ever again become indispensable to the functioning of the state.
Would the political establishment dismantle the architecture of fear, or simply appoint another occupant to the same throne?
Would the security institutions return to their constitutional responsibilities, or remain instruments of political survival?
Would prisoners of conscience receive justice? Would journalists, intellectuals and academics regain their freedom to question authority? Would communities that had endured violence finally have access to truth, accountability and reconciliation?
Would Ethiopia learn to resolve its political differences through constitutional deliberation rather than armed confrontation?
These questions cannot be answered by the departure of one man.
They must be answered by the Ethiopian people themselves.
The country needs more than a change of leadership. It needs a transformation of political culture.
It needs a generation that understands that loyalty to the country is not the same as loyalty to its government; that criticism is not treason; that opposition is not an enemy of national unity; and that public office is a responsibility, not a personal possession.
It needs judges who can say no to presidents and prime ministers, journalists who can investigate without fear, academics who can challenge prevailing political narratives, ministers who can exercise independent judgement and military commanders who understand that their allegiance is to the constitution, the sovereign state and its citizens.
Above all, it needs citizens who refuse to surrender their political judgement to any individual, however charismatic, powerful or persuasive.
This brings us back to Plato.
In the Republic, Plato’s enduring concern was the relationship between justice and political authority. Through Socrates, he challenged the assumption that power itself confers wisdom or legitimacy. His examination of political degeneration reminds us that a society can gradually surrender its freedom when it allows the interests of its rulers to become more important than the interests of the community.
The philosopher’s challenge was not simply to identify a tyrant. It was to understand the conditions that make tyranny possible.
That is the question Ethiopia must confront.
The country must educate its future leaders, but it must also educate its citizens. It must cultivate a political culture in which no individual is beyond scrutiny, no institution is beyond accountability and no community is excluded from the national conversation.
There will be disagreements. There will be competing constitutional visions, historical interpretations and political aspirations. These differences must not be suppressed. They must be discussed, negotiated and reconciled through legitimate institutions and peaceful democratic processes.
A republic is not the property of the person who occupies its highest office. It is a continuing covenant between generations.
“A republic is not the property of the person who occupies its highest office. It is a continuing covenant between generations.”
The fictional death of a ruler may close a chapter in a story. It cannot, by itself, open the next chapter in the history of our beloved Ethiopia.
That responsibility belongs to its people.
Let Ethiopia therefore cease searching for another indispensable ruler. Let it instead build institutions that do not require one.
Let it replace political obedience with constitutional responsibility, fear with freedom, personal authority with institutional accountability and the politics of domination with the pursuit of justice.
Abiy Ahmed is not Ethiopia. No ruler, past or future, is Ethiopia.
Ethiopia must outlive its rulers.
“Abiy Ahmed is not Ethiopia. No ruler, past or future, is Ethiopia.”
And when the next generation looks back upon our time, let it not remember merely the fall of another powerful man. Let it remember that Ethiopians finally learned to build a country in which no man could ever again become greater than the state, and no state could ever again become greater than its people.
Mareshet Yimer Meshesha is an independent analyst. This story is a work of fiction.
20 November 2026
